By Paul Frymer
I do not often write on-line booklet experiences, yet after analyzing the seven overwhelmingly optimistic Amazon reports of "Uneasy Alliances" I felt that somebody had to offer a fact money. i need to preface my very own very destructive evaluation via asserting that i like a few of Frymer's different scholarship, specially at the tensions inherent within the New Deal coalition. i think very in a different way approximately "Uneasy Alliances." here's a direct citation from an e mail I wrote to a graduate university classmate presently after interpreting it for the 1st time:
"But talking of Frymer, have you ever learn the e-book of his assigned for [Professor X's] classification? i assumed it was once beautiful bad. It begins with a believable theoretical thought -- that of curiosity staff 'capture' -- after which makes a large number of historical past in attempting to use it on American politics. My response to it used to be so opposed from the instant i began interpreting that I worry i could have overlooked out on its redeeming features, which it should have given that [Professor X] assigned lots of it."
This quote nonetheless essentially sums up my response to the booklet. Frymer desires to blame the two-party process for the oppression of African americans within the united states, yet his argument is not convincing. he's taking an enticing suggestion ("capture") and attempts to shoe-horn race family in the USA into his theoretical framework. It does not healthy. Blacks were not oppressed as the events colluded to close out their political calls for; they have been oppressed simply because their calls for for political and social equality weren't supported by way of the majority of white american citizens until eventually good into the 20 th century. it's the distribution of personal tastes within the American citizens that used to be guilty, now not the constitution of the social gathering procedure. And it wasn't blacks' "capture" via the Republican get together that allowed their renewed oppression after Reconstruction; it used to be the truth that blacks have been violently disfranchised within the South -- a consequence that was once behind schedule till the tip of the nineteenth century as a result of Republicans' partisan curiosity in safeguarding the vote casting rights of blacks, their most powerful supporters within the quarter. There are comparable logical (not to say genuine -- the publication is stuffed with actual error) issues of Frymer's account of the civil rights period and past. in brief, "Uneasy Alliances" makes a glib and superficially beautiful argument, however it is essentially unconvincing to somebody with a radical clutch of the background of race and politics within the usa. For a extra convincing if a little much less sweeping account of this subject, learn Richard Valelly's the 2 Reconstructions: The fight for Black Enfranchisement (American Politics and Political economic climate sequence) in its place.
Read or Download Uneasy Alliances PDF
Similar elections books
A Harper Perennial Political vintage, The Making of the President 1960 is the groundbreaking nationwide bestseller and Pulitzer Prize-winning account of the 1960 presidential crusade and the election of John F. Kennedy. With this narrative heritage of yankee politics in motion, Theodore White revolutionized the best way presidential campaigns are mentioned.
Within the first finished research of election legislations because the very best courtroom determined Bush v. Gore, Richard L. Hasen rethinks the Court’s position in regulating elections. Drawing at the case documents of the Warren, Burger, and Rehnquist courts, Hasen roots the Court’s intervention in political strategy situations to the landmark 1962 case, Baker v.
This book examines reviews of Romani political participation in japanese and western Europe, supplying an realizing of the rising political area that over eight million Romani voters occupy within the ecu, and addressing concerns on the topic of the socio-political conditions of Romani groups inside of ecu international locations.
How do British elections paintings? What approximately neighborhood elections and by-elections? How are applicants selected? What has been the effect of alterations brought by means of the current govt? How can a typical voter play his or her half? And why accomplish that few humans vote nowadays? Dick Leonard, a political journalist and previous MP, and Roger Mortimore, an opinion pollster, conceal all points of British elections during this up-to-date variation of the normal paintings, together with finished tables of records and effects.
Extra info for Uneasy Alliances
In fact, parties may recognize that it is in their interests to induce swing voters not to vote. This is logical since the goal of party actors is not vote maximizing, but simply winning. For one account of the demobilization of moderate voters by national party campaigns, see Stephen Ansolabehere and Shanto Iyengar, Going Negative: How Attack Ads Shrink and Polarize the Electorate (New York: Free Press, 1995). 56 Adam Przeworski, Capitalism and Social Democracy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985), 101.
Jackson has been so little in public life, that it will be not a little difficult to contrast his opinions on great questions with those of Mr. ”29 As John Aldrich remarks, Van Buren effectively told various state-level political leaders, “Take our popular leader and no controversial policies. We will provide resources to you, so long as you agree to call yourself Democrats. ”30 Van Buren and other Democrats further institutionalized this commitment to avoid sectional conflict by adopting a rule that representation at the party’s nominating convention would be proportional to each Remini, Van Buren and the Making of the Democratic Party, 132.
30 Aldrich, Why Parties? 124. 25 26 38 CHAPTER 2 state’s electoral college votes. The roughly 40 percent representation by southern states was then protected from a majoritarian northern constituency by a second rule that mandated that the party nominee had to win by a two-thirds majority vote. ”31 The party’s commitment to maintaining a strong presence in all sections of the nation required that majorities in both the North and the South support the party’s platform. In 1832, the twothirds rule led to Van Buren’s nomination as the Democratic presidential candidate over the more vehemently pro-slavery candidate, John Calhoun.
Uneasy Alliances by Paul Frymer